Book Review: Comanche Moon by Larry McMurtry

Click here to get more!

Comanche Moon is the second book in the Lonesome Dove series and continues the journey of  Texas Rangers Woodrow Call and Augustus McCrae as they try to tame the west from a dwindling but wildly fierce number of hostile Comanche tribesman. Buffalo Hump continues to lead his people against the encroaching caucasian intruders and we follow his story to the end, and his tale becomes a symbol of the weakening state of the once proud and free native peoples. We also meet Blue Duck, the main antagonist in Lonesome Dove, who is Buffalo Hump's half Comanche half Mexican son. Blue Duck never got along with his father and his disrespect for the old ways leads to him being cast out by his father. 

On the other side of the fence, we get to meet the incomparable Captain Inish Scull and the eccentric Famous Shoes. Famous shoes is a Kickapoo tracker who never rides a horse and yet somehow is always ahead of the Rangers he is tracking for. He leaves for days on end but always comes back with interesting information. He knows the land and helps Inish Scull when his exceptionally large horse is stolen by the infamous horse thief Kicking Wolf. Inish finds out how harsh the frontier really is when he finally finds out what happened to his horse. 

The book mainly focuses on the perspective of the Comanche people while forwarding the character-driven work he started in the previous entry. Call, McCrae, Pea Eye, Deets, Newt, and many more characters are all there and we finally get to see the evolution of Call's relationship with Maggie, the whore whose son Call won't claim. We also find out about what happens to Long Bill Coleman, who made his way through the torment of the death march in Dead Man's Walk, and Clara Forsythe, who Gus will always pine for. 

The Lonesome Dove Series is a must-read for fans of the western genre and Comanche Moon acts as a tribute to the transition from the old ways to the new. Everyone gets older and people die. No matter how much you want to cling to the past things change and you can either change too or fade away into history. The characters are treated and developed with care and respect and we see things from their respective perspectives. Everyone has their own motivations for what they do and no one's perfect. In summary, this book is fun, easy to read, well-paced, and well written and you should read it. 

*I haven't seen the movie based on it but I'm sure it makes a good companion to the book. 

Read my other reviews from Larry McMurtry Novels:

Dead Man's Walk

https://joesnotesblog.com/blog/book-review-dead-mans-walk-by-larry-mcmurtry?rq=mcmurtry%20

Lonesome Dove

https://joesnotesblog.com/blog/book-review-lonesome-dove-by-larry-mcmurtry?rq=mcmurtry

Book Review: Dead Man's Walk by Larry McMurtry

Click here to get more!

After reading "Lonesome Dove" by Larry McMurtry and finding out that it was just one in a series of Western books written around the characters of Gus McCrae and Woodrow Call I went out and immediately purchased "Dead Man's Walk". For my review of "Lonesome Dove" check the link below. I was so impressed and enthralled with the storytelling in "Lonesome Dove" that I knew that I would enjoy another adventure and this book does not disappoint.

"Dead Man's Walk" is a prequel to "Lonesome Dove" and offers up the story of Call and Gus as they begin their careers as Texas Rangers. Where "Lonesome Dove" shows the two characters in their wizened forms, "Dead Man's Walk" shows them as real greenhorns poised to be molded into the hardened leaders of men they would become. Knowing that they will survive all the ordeals in "Dead Man's Walk" does not take away from the excitement and intrigue the book delivers but instead opens the characters up for a more intimate and raw examination.

The book begins with the two new recruits on an expedition into the baren American frontier in hopes of discovering a usable road west of San Antonio along the Rio Grande river but what they find on the trail is only their own ineptitude. This is when we are introduced to the main characters that will accompany Gus and Call for the bulk of the book. We meet Matilda Roberts, also known as "The Great Western", who is the only woman on the journey but as she is larger than most men and braver and more surly than most as well she doesn't take a side role in the ensemble. We also meet Bigfoot Wallace and Shadrach, who are the most experienced frontiersmen of the group and provide Gus and Call with mentorship throughout their hard journeys. Along with about twenty others, they make their way along the Mexican border.

Not far into this, their first rangering expedition, the group runs head-on into a small group of Comanche warriors and discover that the native people are not to be fucked with. One of the groups' members is killed within spitting distance and they don't even notice. Then they watch as one of their friends is scalped while running away from the Comanche Chief named Buffalo Hump. This wouldn't be the last time they see Buffalo Hump either. Not by a long shot.

Not long after our main characters return to the relative peace of civilization they find that another expedition is preparing to leave and this one would be an even better opportunity to find fame, fortune and whatever it is that Call's after. The new expedition is from San Antonio to Santa Fe and is headed up by an ex-pirate with a pension for pomposity and violence named Caleb Cobb. The expedition starts with over one hundred members but within just a few weeks dwindles steadily down as many simply turn back. The men that are left end up running directly into the wrath of the Comanches lead by Buffalo Hump, who does everything he can to terrorize the soldiers.

Soon the men split up only to find that they are well into Mexican territory and that the Mexican army knows they are there. With no water and no food, the soldiers have to decide whether to fight the superior Mexican army or surrender. The decision would be another in a long line of circumstances that lead to pain and suffering, which is really the main event featured in this book. It could have entitled "The Ordeals of the Ignorant" or "A series of horrible yet avoidable events". The hardships that the characters endure are seemingly never-ending and as a reader, it was never boring. 

I am not sure what I would think about this book had I not read "Lonesome Dove" first. I might think that it is a bit one dimensional as there is not much under the surface of the text. The plain language of the narrator and characters does not leave much room for mystery or suspense but the whole thing seems like it is plucked out of a 19th-century western frontier campfire story. Because I have read "Lonesome Dove" I was excited to read about what made Call and Gus the hardened cowboys they became. I was even more enticed getting to know the accompanying characters Matilda, Bigfoot, and Shadrach.  I definitely recommend this book to anyone who likes westerns even if they have not read any of the other Lonesome Dove series books before but if possible I think reading "Lonesome Dove" first is ideal. It is a deeper book that explores more of the emotional side of the characters as they reach retirement age. Also, below is a link to the very long movie based on "Dead Man's Walk" and I highly recommend watching it as a supplement to the book. The story and dialogue are essentially right out of the book and might be the most accurate adaptation I have seen. If you like westerns or want to try something new please check out these books. 

Lonesome Dove Review Here:

https://joesnotesblog.com/blog/book-review-lonesome-dove-by-larry-mcmurtry

The Movie:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ta3yLM2m5Ho

Book Review: Lonesome Dove by Larry McMurtry

Click here to join my mailing list and stay up to date!

Lonesome Dove is an engulfing western tale about more than just a cattle drive to Montana, which is one of the driving forces for the plot, by the way, but it is really about loneliness and regret. Woodrow Call and Augustus McCrae are two retired Texas Rangers that take the advice their old rangering buddy, Jake Spoon, tells them of the riches they could make as the first cattle ranchers in Montana, which is only three thousand miles away from their small ranch in Texas. Captain Call, as they call him, decides to take Jake's advice and amasses a three thousand-headed herd of cattle and horses and a dozen or so green cowboys, and, along with the non-stop communicator Gus, they all make their way across almost three thousand miles of a mostly unsettled and completely wild frontier. None of the men had previously been that far north and none knew of the dangers that were waiting for them.

From snakes and lightning to Indians and stampedes the group discovers a plethora of life-threatening opportunities on their path to Montana. Jake Spoon takes up with a whore from Lonesome Dove named Lorena who pays a heavy price for her fare across the desert wastelands to somewhere better. Along with such environmental hazards, we soon find that Jake Spoon is being tracked by a lawman from Arkansas named July Johnson, who has his own demons to contend with. Namely, his wife Elmira, who decides to seek out an old flame while July is gone with her son Joe tracking down the outlaw with a utensil for a last name. Unfortunately, July's story is not riddled with the kind of success and glory he was after. This book is filled with surprises that challenge the expectations of the reader as well as the characters within it. Failed expectations all around. 

I love the writing style in this book. The narrator speaks in a way that exudes period-specific authenticity and it is if they are the best storyteller in the old west. The narrator is smart and witty. They really pay attention to what's important in the world and tells the story as if they really care about the characters. The narrator knows the characters' histories, thoughts, and feelings and represents them in a way that straddles the line between intimate and detached. The inner turmoil that accompanies the human condition, especially the harsh life one would experience in the 19th century American West is displayed with vivid exposition. 

Over the course of the book, the main characters are methodically massaged into existence and soon they are as real as your closest friends. The dialogue also seems very authentic and captures a time when people spoke plainly but not without style. Augustus McCrae is well known to be quite the talker and to those that enjoy conversation, a cattle drive can be a lonesome place indeed. Many westerns focus on quickdraw duels, bad guys in black hats and small-town life but not this book. This book is about humanity and all the good and bad that comes with it. It's about the relationships we choose and the relationships we don't. It's about the decisions we're forced to make and the times we decide not to make one. 

I enjoyed reading this book very much and plan to read more in the series. There are three more books and I am sure they are just as enthralling. The mini-series, by the same name, starring Robert Duvall, Tommy Lee Jones, and Danny Glover is a great representation of the book and makes a good supplement after reading the book. It isn't often that I get so wrapped up into a book that I can make it through over 800 pages and wish there was more. Since there are more I have to decide whether I want to make the commitment back into the world Larry McMurtry has created. A world so rich with detail that it can take a little out of you just imagining it. I recommend this book.